May 19, - A cycling enthusiast asked me about helmets. the scalp is protected from a direct impact but the brain is still vigorously jostled. head on the pavement with or without the protection of a helmet, which would you choose?
If a car manufacturer suddenly told you fenders were useless, you might raise an eyebrow. If a sporting goods designer told hockey goalies that their serial-killer masks didn't prevent concussions, there might ensue a fight.
So when a neurosurgeon offers that cycle helmets are pointless, you might imagine that the more bellicose spoke of yoour cycling fraternity might wonder if he's been in the pub all day.
However, Dr. Henry Marsh, a neurosurgeon at St. George's Hospital in London, believes many cycling helmets are simply "too flimsy.
There, he threw caution to an erudite wind by saying: In the countries where bike helmets are compulsory there has been no reduction in bike injuries whatsoever. There are surely those who would differ.
Construction workers use hard hats. Soldiers wear helmets in combat. Eggs are sold in protective containers rather than dropped individually into shopping bags; the principle is the same.
It seems to me that the reaction against helmets for cycling is more emotional than evidence-based. Helmets clearly offer at least some degree of insurance for the individual.
Whether individuals should be compelled by legislation to protect themselves is another matter entirely, a decision that I am willing to leave to others.
Harriet Hall, MD also known as The SkepDoc, is a retired family physician who writes about pseudoscience and questionable medical practices.
During a long career as an Air Force physician, she held do bike helmets protect your brain positions from flight surgeon to DBMS Director of Base Medical Services and did everything from delivering babies to taking the controls of a B Nevertheless common sense suggests surrounding your head with some kali dirt bike helmets of protection must offer some cushioning from head impact — a view which neurological studies definitely support.
At First Aid for Life we understand the importance of knowing exactly what to do, should you be involved in a bicycle accident — or be the first to arrive at the scene of one.
As such, we offer hands on, practical first aid coursesas well as a tailored, online course specifically for cyclistsa course is designed as an introduction to basic first aid in a cycling environment. First Aid for Life provides this information do bike helmets protect your brain guidance and it is not in any way a substitute for medical advice.
First Aid for Life is not responsible or liable for any diagnosis made, or actions taken based on this information. It is strongly advised that you attend a First Aid course to understand what to do in a medical emergency.
First aid saves lives - ten powerful reasons to learn first aid this year. Rock climbing most certainly will protect a flybar bike helmets from a rock falling from above, onto their head, but this is different do bike helmets protect your brain other activities. They are likely to be wrapped up in a bubble of a false security. Whether horse riding, cycling, skiing etc, if the person falls, it is very unusual they land head first.
If they do land head first, it is more likely they land face first and a helmet will offer little protection in those incidents. Wearing a helmet does not automatically put a participant at a higher skill level, these must be learnt first. It should be understood that the helmet is a device for slowing down the moving of the brain by a rapid deceleration and therefore shock damage.
Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report Atlanta, GA: Page last reviewed: January 28, Content source: To receive email updates about this page, enter your email address: What's the best bicycle helmet to buy? The most important things to think about when you buy a helmet are: Does it fit snugly and stay properly in position on your head?
Is it light and comfortable?
Does it have enough ventilation holes so it stays cool? Do you like the look of it and will you actually wear it?
Does it meet the latest consumer standards? When should I replace a helmet? Do I really have to wear a helmet?
Do helmets really help? Could helmets put people off cycling? What do the studies say?
Scientific studies of cycle injuries paint s one helmets mixed picture: A recent two-year study of injuries treated in braim hospital by Dinh et al found that "A lower proportion of people wearing helmets had significant head injury But that doesn't mean helmets are guaranteed to help in every situation. A recent study of injured cyclists by Rivara, Thompson, and Thompson concluded that "Prevention of serious bicycle injuries cannot be accomplished through helmet use alone, and may require separation of cyclists from motor do bike helmets protect your brain.
Whether a helmet helps you also depends on who you are. They profit most by wearing a helmet.
Sponsored links. A superb resource covering literally everything you could ever want to know about helmets. Materials for Bicycle Helmets: For the more scientifically minded, this interesting research paper explains how different helmet foams compare in energy-absorbing performance.
Cyclist safety: Arguments for cycle helmets from Brake, the UK protext safety charity. Bicycle Safety Publications: A range of helpful safety advice from the U.
Consumer Product Safety Commission. The Guardian, January 4, Campaigners criticize official UK advice recommending cyclists should wear helmets. The Guardian, September 22,
News:If you had to choose between giving a child a helmet or the education about The net result is no overall protection, and possibly even an overall negative effect. Most of us have heard that "bicycle helmets can prevent up to 85% of head it against the road or a car (causing traumatic brain injury because the brain is still.
Leave a Comment